It was a pleasant afternoon and I had a pleasant book….
I was sitting with an exquisite cup of white tea in a beautiful local tea shop. They serve delicious teas made from leaves growing on ancient trees, picked by hand in the Spring and then lovingly hand-processed on very small family farms in very remote regions of China.
My environment was perfect.
At the table next to me sat a couple.
The man was in quite a pleasant mood. He was telling the woman about something that had happened that morning. He was enjoying talking with her and enjoying the telling. He finished and smiled at her.
The woman spoke: “Why didn’t you ask her? I would have thought that would have been the first thing you would have asked her.”
The woman’s question seemed polite, but her tone of voice had a slight edge, an unspoken quality of “I’m trying hard to be very polite, but I really don’t get how you could have done something so wrong.”
I’m sure she was completely unaware of her tone. Most people are.
I picked up my book and pretended to read because I knew where this conversation was going. I didn’t even know what they were talking about, but I knew they were headed for a fight.
Can you see how the question itself makes him wrong? I knew he was going to defend what he did. In other words, he was going to get “defensive”.